Is the
current refugee crisis gripping the European Union “all America’s fault”? That is how
my critique of US foreign policy was characterized in a recent interview on the
Fox Business Channel. I do not
blame the host for making this claim, but I think it is important to clarify
the point.
It has become
common to discount any criticism of US foreign policy as “blaming America
first.”
It is a convenient way of avoiding a real discussion.
If aggressive US policy in the Middle East – for example in Iraq – results in
the creation of terrorist organizations like al-Qaeda in Iraq, is pointing out
the unintended consequences of bad policy blaming America? Is it “blaming
America” to point out that blowback – like we saw on 9/11 – can be the result
of unwise US foreign policy actions like stationing US troops in Saudi Arabia?
In the Fox interview I pointed out that the current refugee crisis is largely caused
by bad US foreign policy actions. The US government decides on
regime change for a particular country – in this case, Syria – destabilizes the
government, causes social chaos, and destroys the economy, and we are supposed
to be surprised that so many people are desperate to leave? Is pointing this out blaming America, or is
it blaming that part of the US government that makes such foolish policies?
Accusing
those who criticize US foreign policy of “blaming America” is pretty selective,
however. Such accusations are never leveled at those who criticize a US
pullback. For example, most neocons argue that the current
crisis in Iraq is all Obama’s fault for pulling US troops out of the country.
Are they “blaming America first” for the mess? No one ever says that. Just like
they never explain why the troops were removed from Iraq: the US demanded
complete immunity for troops and contractors and the Iraqi government refused.
Iraq was not
a stable country when the US withdrew its troops anyway. As soon
as the US stopped paying the Sunnis not to attack the Iraqi government, they
started attacking the Iraqi government. Why? Because the US attack on Iraq led
to a government that was closely allied to Iran and the Sunnis could not live
with that! It was not the US withdrawal from Iraq that created the current
instability but the invasion. The
same is true with US regime change policy toward Syria. How many
Syrians were streaming out of Syria before US support for Islamist rebels there
made the country unlivable? Is pointing out this consequence of bad US policy
also blaming America first?
Last year I was asked by another Fox program whether I was not “blaming America” when I criticized
the increasingly confrontational US stand toward Russia. Here’s how
I put it then:
I don't blame America. I am America, you are America. I
don't blame you. I blame bad policy. I blame the interventionists. I blame the neoconservatives who preach
this stuff, who believe in it like a religion -- that they have to promote
American goodness even if you have to bomb and kill people.
In short, I don’t blame America; I blame neocons.
No comments:
Post a Comment